Copyright © Graeme MacKay. Please check for MacKay's posting and publication rules by clicking here.
The Hamilton Spectator
Recent cartoons
Tuesday July 20, 2010
Faced with a $20 billion deficit, provincial Finance Minister Dwight Duncan is meeting today with public sector unions to discuss his plan to freeze their members’ wages.

There is an echo here of the early 1990s, when then premier Bob Rae tried to negotiate a “social contract” with the province’s public sector unions. The unions refused to negotiate, so Rae imposed wage rollbacks on them by fiat. That, in turn, alienated the NDP government from its political base and helped pave the way for the election of Mike Harris and the Conservatives.

Could Premier Dalton McGuinty’s Liberal government be headed in the same direction? Not likely, because there are two key differences between then and now.

First of all, McGuinty and Duncan are not proposing to rip up existing collective bargaining agreements, as Rae did. Rather, they will wait until those contracts expire – most of the major ones have a couple of years left to run – before negotiating a freeze.

Secondly, what happened under Harris -- tens of thousands of public servants were fired – is still fresh in the minds of most union leaders. The same could happen again if the unions fight the Liberals and the Conservatives regain power under Tim Hudak, a Harris clone. One hopes, then, that Duncan’s words today will find a more receptive audience than did Rae’s social contract pitch 17 years ago.

With private sector unions already suffering much worse in the form of wage rollbacks and layoffs, it seems perfectly reasonable to call for a public sector freeze. Indeed, the government has already imposed a wage freeze on non-union employees.

Opponents of a freeze offer essentially two alternatives: keep running deficits or tax the rich. Neither is tenable. Continued...

Echo of Bob Rae and Mike Harris
Center lower